regen findings-index (validate gate); M-84 verdict tokens on D211/D214/D217 status cells

docs/dev/findings-index.csv

@@ -53,13 +53,13 @@ D179,FIXED,Packaged build crashes after the logos —,"Diagnosed, not fixed —"
 D180,PARTIAL,"Native-PC input pass (M-XX QoL run, qol/native-pc-input-menu, port-only).","LANDED, port-only, no #ifdef PORT."
 D181,PARTIAL,Game.ScreenShakeIntensity —,"LANDED behind config, default = original."
 D184,PARTIAL,F10 port-layer options overlay —,"LANDED, port-only, no #ifdef PORT in src/."
-D211,MOSTLY-VERIFIED,"PC FOV slider — Video.FovScale (M-83; M-84 refix + front-end gate).","M-84: fast3d matrix hook only scaled pure-perspective loads (watch model/sky), missed the CPU-combined world matrix; moved to game-side fovy scale (fr.c, #ifdef PORT), gated to non-title stages. User-verified: menu unaffected + in-level view widens. Nits: HUD-static / aim-zoom eyeball at ~120. D218 (draw distance) split out + parked."
+D211,PARTIAL,"PC FOV slider — Video.FovScale (M-83 QoL wave, port-only, WIDESCREEN-FOV-PLAN.md Phase 4).",PARTIAL — M-84 refix:
 D212,PARTIAL,Anisotropic-filtering config wiring —,"LANDED, port-only. Build clean."
 D213,PARTIAL,On-screen FPS readout —,"LANDED, port-only. Build clean; bunker1 no-op confirmed."
-D214,PARTIAL,"Keyboard rebinding — [Input.Bind] config section (M-83; M-84 doc fix).","LANDED, port-only. M-84 user test: alt/ctrl PASS. Doc bug fixed (no code change): section is [Input.Bind] not [Bind] (config groups by last dot), or use a fully-qualified Input.Bind.Fire= line. Watch-menu Esc-to-back still unwired (pre-existing)."
+D214,PARTIAL,"Keyboard rebinding — [Input.Bind] config section (M-83, port-only, PD parity, Phase 4 debt).",PARTIAL — M-84: code PASS (alt/ctrl); one doc-only fix.
 D215,FIXED,1P weapon viewmodel never drew in-level —,"FIXED (src/game/gunfire.c, #ifdef PORT)."
-D217,OPEN,"1P viewmodel + 3rd-person Bond model textures render garbled (green/blue/yellow) — wrong/stale palette on model-DL CI textures (M-84, user QA; surfaced by D215). D161 family.","Observed, not investigated. Next: GE_TEXDUMP on a weapon texture; check gDPLoadTLUT reaches gfx_pc.cpp for model DLs."
-D218,LOGGED,"Wide FOV exposes the per-level FarFog draw-distance/fog boundary — blue artifacting down long sightlines (Dam tunnel) at high FovScale (M-84, user QA).","Fix proposed + parked: Video.DrawDistance multiplier on FarFog at bgfog.c:305 (#ifdef PORT) + Video.DrawDistanceAutoFov toggle (default couples draw distance to FovScale)."
+D217,OPEN,1P weapon viewmodel + third-person Bond model textures render garbled —,"OPEN — observed, not investigated (M-84)."
+D218,PROPOSED,Wide FOV exposes the per-level draw-distance / fog boundary —,"Logged (M-84), fix proposed + parked."
 D85,OPEN,room primary/secondary DL → texLoadFromGdl garbage,"OPEN (safety-netted; widen/pool fixes landed, geometry now renders)"
 D86 · D87,RESOLVED,modelInitRwData truncated ptr · attract-demo BE ramromfilestructure,resolved
 D88.4,RESOLVED,propDefs polymorphic record stream not byteswapped → setupDoor crash,resolved (d88_propdefs.py); layout audit M-20 → D132

docs/dev/findings.md

@@ -427,12 +427,12 @@ covers D24–D69; the log continues in §H (D32 procedure, D70–D121).
 | D180 | **Native-PC input pass (M-XX QoL run, `qol/native-pc-input-menu`, port-only).** Three parts, all config-gated with default = prior behaviour: **(WI-1) `Input.MouseCaptureMode`** (0 = legacy always-grab; 1 = Quake-style click-to-lock) in `port/src/input.c` + `port/src/video.c` — in mode 1 the OS cursor is free until a click lands in the game window (`SDL_MOUSEBUTTONDOWN` → `inputNotifyClick`), and ESC / focus-loss / entering any front-end menu (`current_menu != MENU_RUN_STAGE`) frees it again; re-entering a stage while still "armed" re-locks so unpausing needs no click. `reconcileGrab()` runs once per controller-0 poll. Mouse buttons are suppressed from the game while the cursor is free in-stage (no phantom fire). Controller paths untouched. **(WI-2) absolute-cursor menu tracking** — when capture mode is on and the cursor is free in a menu, the D165/D169 pointer P-controller takes its target from the real cursor's absolute window position mapped onto the live virtual front-end rect (`getPlayer_c_screen*`), giving true 1:1 tracking instead of the relative-delta estimator. Relative path unchanged for legacy/grabbed. **(B3) `Input.MouseAimSpeed` default 25 → 16** (aim mode still overshot at 25 per the backlog). | LANDED, port-only, no `#ifdef PORT`. Build 241/241, `-level_09` framediff 3/3 within threshold (unregressed), `GE_STARTMENU` menu boot crash-free. **Feel-checks owed** (headless can't drive the mouse): click-to-lock ergonomics, absolute menu tracking, the new aim-speed default. |
 | D181 | **`Game.ScreenShakeIntensity` — first route-(b) `src/` gameplay-cosmetic hook (M-XX QoL run).** `src/fr.c viShake()` gains a single `#ifdef PORT` line — `intensity *= portScreenShakeScale;` (extern `f32`, defined + `configRegisterFloat`'d 0.0–10.0 in `port/src/video.c`) — before the existing clamp. Default `1.0f` ⇒ exact no-op, every headless golden dump byte-unaffected; `0.0` disables explosion/effect screen shake, up to `10.0` exaggerates it. N64 build (no `-DPORT`) keeps the original line verbatim. Precedent per `docs/BACKLOG.md` "Fun features → screen-shake intensity slider" and AGENTS.md #2's documented-exception path. Same policy class as a future FOV hook. | LANDED behind config, default = original. Build green. |
 | D184 | **F10 port-layer options overlay — the approach-(C) surface from `OPTIONS-MENU-PLAN.md` (M-37).** New `port/src/optionsoverlay.c` + `port/include/optionsoverlay.h`: an immediate-mode overlay drawn as its own fast3d 2D DL, appended after the game DL in `gfx_pc.cpp gfx_run()` (`optionsOverlayEmit()` → NULL when closed ⇒ **zero bytes appended, golden dumps byte-identical**). F10 toggles (`video.c videoPumpEvents`, next to F12); while open, `input.c inputComputePad(0)` returns a neutral pad and routes arrows/enter/wheel/mouse-buttons to `optionsOverlayHandleInput()` (mirrors the WI-1/D180 swallow). ESC closes; `configSave()` on close. `config.c` gains `configForEachOption()` + a `configSetOptionMeta()` label/step/enum side table (no per-key knowledge in config.c). Live knobs (VSync/FpsCap/TextureFilter via `videoRequestLiveConfig()`; mouse + screen-shake via the registered pointer) apply immediately; MSAA tagged "(restart)". v1 rows per plan §3: VSync, FpsCap, MSAA, TextureFilter, MouseAimSpeed, MouseTurnSpeed, MouseInvertY, MouseCaptureMode, ScreenShakeIntensity. | **LANDED, port-only, no `#ifdef PORT` in `src/`.** Build links 241/241. **Runtime verification NOT run this session** — the headless env kills the GUI process after ~8 s and `gfx_opengl_dump_bound_fbo` writes 0-byte PPMs here, so framediff / 60 s soak / overlay-frame eyeball are all owed on an interactive machine. Overlay-closed no-op is code-evident (emit returns NULL before touching the DL buffer). |
-| D211 | **PC FOV slider — `Video.FovScale` (M-83 QoL wave, port-only, `WIDESCREEN-FOV-PLAN.md` Phase 4).** fast3d applies a multiplicative half-angle scale to every *perspective* projection matrix as it is loaded (`gfx_apply_fov_scale()` in `gfx_pc.cpp gfx_sp_matrix`, on the `G_MTX_PROJECTION | G_MTX_LOAD` path only — GE always reloads its view projection via `guPerspectiveF` at `fr.c:725`, so a relative `G_MTX_MUL` onto an already-scaled matrix cannot compound). Columns 0 and 1 are scaled by the same factor `tan(half_orig)/tan(half_adj)` → H and V FOV widen uniformly, aspect ratio exactly preserved (no stretch), and because the game rewrites fovy every frame for aim-zoom the scale composes with zoom for free. Ortho matrices (`P[3][3]==1`) are left untouched so HUD/menu 2D is unaffected. `Video.FovScale` = percent of the original vertical FOV, 50–150, **default 100 ⇒ `g_fov_scale == 1.0f` ⇒ guarded early-return, zero FP ops on the matrix ⇒ golden dumps byte-identical**. F10 overlay row "FOV scale %". Math checked offline (`s=1.25 → fovy 60°→75°`, aspect held at 1.3333). | **LANDED, port-only, no `#ifdef PORT`.** Build clean; `bunker1` framediff worst_cell 12.219 vs 12.221 baseline (= render noise, no-op confirmed). **M-84 refix — the fast3d hook only scaled *pure* perspective loads; GE draws the world through `g_CurrentPlayer->field_10E0`, a projection × view matrix pre-combined on the CPU (`bondview2.c:8224`) that failed the `gfx_apply_fov_scale` guard, so only the pause/watch model + sky FOV changed (user report).** Moved the scale game-side to the `guPerspectiveF` chokepoint (`fr.c:718`, `#ifdef PORT`, `frFovY *= portFovScale`, clamp 160°), which lands *before* the CPU combine; fast3d `gfx_apply_fov_scale`/`gfx_set_fov_scale` removed; `port/src/video.c` sets `f32 portFovScale`. Also gated to `lvlGetCurrentStageToLoad() != LEVELID_TITLE` — the front end (main menu / file+mission select / briefing) renders through the same path (`lv.c lvlRender`) and its 3D is authored at a fixed FOV. **User-verified: front end unaffected + in-level view widens (Dam tunnel at high FovScale).** Nits: HUD-static / aim-zoom-composes eyeball at ~120. Caveat: `currentPlayerSetCameraScale` frustum-cull / screen↔world math stays at nominal FOV → edge geometry culls a hair early at large scale (cosmetic). Wide FOV also exposes the per-level draw-distance boundary → **D218** (logged, parked). |
+| D211 | **PC FOV slider — `Video.FovScale` (M-83 QoL wave, port-only, `WIDESCREEN-FOV-PLAN.md` Phase 4).** fast3d applies a multiplicative half-angle scale to every *perspective* projection matrix as it is loaded (`gfx_apply_fov_scale()` in `gfx_pc.cpp gfx_sp_matrix`, on the `G_MTX_PROJECTION | G_MTX_LOAD` path only — GE always reloads its view projection via `guPerspectiveF` at `fr.c:725`, so a relative `G_MTX_MUL` onto an already-scaled matrix cannot compound). Columns 0 and 1 are scaled by the same factor `tan(half_orig)/tan(half_adj)` → H and V FOV widen uniformly, aspect ratio exactly preserved (no stretch), and because the game rewrites fovy every frame for aim-zoom the scale composes with zoom for free. Ortho matrices (`P[3][3]==1`) are left untouched so HUD/menu 2D is unaffected. `Video.FovScale` = percent of the original vertical FOV, 50–150, **default 100 ⇒ `g_fov_scale == 1.0f` ⇒ guarded early-return, zero FP ops on the matrix ⇒ golden dumps byte-identical**. F10 overlay row "FOV scale %". Math checked offline (`s=1.25 → fovy 60°→75°`, aspect held at 1.3333). | **PARTIAL — M-84 refix: game-side FOV scale (`src/fr.c`, `#ifdef PORT`), front-end gated, user-verified.** Original M-83 note follows. LANDED, port-only; build clean; `bunker1` framediff worst_cell 12.219 vs 12.221 baseline (= render noise, no-op confirmed). **M-84 refix — the fast3d hook only scaled *pure* perspective loads; GE draws the world through `g_CurrentPlayer->field_10E0`, a projection × view matrix pre-combined on the CPU (`bondview2.c:8224`) that failed the `gfx_apply_fov_scale` guard, so only the pause/watch model + sky FOV changed (user report).** Moved the scale game-side to the `guPerspectiveF` chokepoint (`fr.c:718`, `#ifdef PORT`, `frFovY *= portFovScale`, clamp 160°), which lands *before* the CPU combine; fast3d `gfx_apply_fov_scale`/`gfx_set_fov_scale` removed; `port/src/video.c` sets `f32 portFovScale`. Also gated to `lvlGetCurrentStageToLoad() != LEVELID_TITLE` — the front end (main menu / file+mission select / briefing) renders through the same path (`lv.c lvlRender`) and its 3D is authored at a fixed FOV. **User-verified: front end unaffected + in-level view widens (Dam tunnel at high FovScale).** Nits: HUD-static / aim-zoom-composes eyeball at ~120. Caveat: `currentPlayerSetCameraScale` frustum-cull / screen↔world math stays at nominal FOV → edge geometry culls a hair early at large scale (cosmetic). Wide FOV also exposes the per-level draw-distance boundary → **D218** (logged, parked). |
 | D212 | **Anisotropic-filtering config wiring — `Video.Anisotropy` (M-83 QoL wave, port-only).** The fast3d GL backend already implemented `set_anisotropy_level` / `get_max_anisotropy_level` and applied `GL_TEXTURE_MAX_ANISOTROPY` on mipmapped tiles with a hardcoded `current_anisotropy_level = 4`; there was no way to configure it. Added the `gfx_set_anisotropy_level()` extern-C wrapper in `gfx_pc.cpp` (clamps to `[1, GL max]`, `reset_texture_state()` so live changes take), declared in `gfx_api.h`, and `Video.Anisotropy` (1–16) in `port/src/video.c` wired through `videoApplyImageOptions()` on init + live-config. **Default 4 = the value fast3d already applied ⇒ no visual delta at defaults.** F10 overlay row "Anisotropic". | **LANDED, port-only.** Build clean. **Owed:** eyeball at 16× on a grazing surface (Depot roof / Dam walkway) vs 1×. |
 | D213 | **On-screen FPS readout — `Video.DisplayFPS` (M-83 QoL wave, port-only, PD parity).** `port/src/optionsoverlay.c` samples frame time once per emitted frame (`fpsTick()` via `sysGetMicroseconds()`, ~0.5 s window) and, when enabled, emits a small top-right green "N FPS" DL even while the F10 panel is closed. Config-only knob (kept off the 13-row panel, which is at its documented layout limit — matches PD, whose `DisplayFPS` is also file-only). **Default 0 ⇒ `optionsOverlayEmit()` still returns NULL when the panel is closed ⇒ golden dumps byte-identical.** | **LANDED, port-only.** Build clean; `bunker1` no-op confirmed. **Owed:** eyeball that the counter reads a sane ~30 and doesn't overlap the HUD. |
-| D214 | **Keyboard rebinding — `[Input.Bind]` config section (M-83, port-only, PD parity, Phase 4 debt).** `port/src/input.c` gains 12 gameplay actions (Forward/Back/StrafeLeft/StrafeRight/TurnLeft/TurnRight/Fire/Aim/Action/Cancel/LeanLeft/Start), each a comma-separated list of up to 4 SDL scancode names (`Input.Bind.Forward = W,Up` …). `inputRebuildBinds()` (called from `inputInit()`, after `configLoad()`) parses them via `SDL_GetScancodeFromName`; unknown names log a warning and are skipped. The old hardcoded `keyDown(ks, SDL_SCANCODE_*)` block in `inputComputePad` is replaced by `actHeld(ks, IA_*)`. Mouse buttons (fire = LMB, aim = RMB) stay hardwired; the mouse-wheel weapon-cycle A-pulse is untouched. **Defaults reproduce the previous FPS layout exactly — verified: all 20 default key names round-trip to the identical `SDL_Scancode` the old code used (`SDL_GetScancodeFromName` test, 0 mismatches).** Config-file only (no in-overlay text entry — matches PD, whose rebinding is also file-driven); a fresh `ge007.ini` gets the full `[Input.Bind]` block with the defaults visible. | **LANDED, port-only, no `#ifdef PORT`.** Build clean. **M-84 user test: alt/ctrl rebind PASS.** One doc bug fixed (no code change): `config.c` groups keys by the substring *before the last `.`*, so the section header is **`[Input.Bind]`**, not `[Bind]` — earlier finding/commit/QOL text was wrong. Working syntax: put `Fire = Left Alt` under `[Input.Bind]`, or write a fully-qualified `Input.Bind.Fire = Left Alt` line anywhere (`config.c:307`). Separately: the pause→**watch menu** does not wire Esc→back (still Enter to open/close/back) — pre-existing, `options.c`, minor. |
+| D214 | **Keyboard rebinding — `[Input.Bind]` config section (M-83, port-only, PD parity, Phase 4 debt).** `port/src/input.c` gains 12 gameplay actions (Forward/Back/StrafeLeft/StrafeRight/TurnLeft/TurnRight/Fire/Aim/Action/Cancel/LeanLeft/Start), each a comma-separated list of up to 4 SDL scancode names (`Input.Bind.Forward = W,Up` …). `inputRebuildBinds()` (called from `inputInit()`, after `configLoad()`) parses them via `SDL_GetScancodeFromName`; unknown names log a warning and are skipped. The old hardcoded `keyDown(ks, SDL_SCANCODE_*)` block in `inputComputePad` is replaced by `actHeld(ks, IA_*)`. Mouse buttons (fire = LMB, aim = RMB) stay hardwired; the mouse-wheel weapon-cycle A-pulse is untouched. **Defaults reproduce the previous FPS layout exactly — verified: all 20 default key names round-trip to the identical `SDL_Scancode` the old code used (`SDL_GetScancodeFromName` test, 0 mismatches).** Config-file only (no in-overlay text entry — matches PD, whose rebinding is also file-driven); a fresh `ge007.ini` gets the full `[Input.Bind]` block with the defaults visible. | **PARTIAL — M-84: code PASS (alt/ctrl); one doc-only fix.** LANDED, port-only, no `#ifdef PORT`; build clean. One doc bug fixed (no code change): `config.c` groups keys by the substring *before the last `.`*, so the section header is **`[Input.Bind]`**, not `[Bind]` — earlier finding/commit/QOL text was wrong. Working syntax: put `Fire = Left Alt` under `[Input.Bind]`, or write a fully-qualified `Input.Bind.Fire = Left Alt` line anywhere (`config.c:307`). Separately: the pause→**watch menu** does not wire Esc→back (still Enter to open/close/back) — pre-existing, `options.c`, minor. |
 | D215 | **1P weapon viewmodel never drew in-level — `gunRenderFirstPersonGunModels` builds its `ModelRenderData` from a reinterpret across separately-declared adjacent globals that only works on N64 (M-83, D3x/ABI class; retires VIEWMODEL-RESEARCH.md).** The N64 line `renderdata = *(ModelRenderData *)&D_80035CC0;` (`gunfire.c`) casts the lone `u32 D_80035CC0 = 0;` to a whole `ModelRenderData` and reads on into the next declared global, `u32 D_80035CC4[] = {1, 3, 0, 0, …}` (`gun.c`) — yielding `{ basemtx=0, zbufferenabled=1, flags=3, rest=0 }` **only because the N64 linker lays the two globals out contiguously in declaration order and pointers are 4 B**. On x86-64 it breaks twice: `ModelRenderData`'s three pointer members (`basemtx`/`gdl`/`mtxlist`) widen 4→8 B so `flags` is no longer at struct offset 8, and C guarantees nothing about the two globals' relative placement. Measured (`GE_DVM=1`, BUNKER1): `renderdata.flags == 0`, so **every** weapon-model DL node was gated off at `modelRenderNodeGundl` (`(renderdata->flags & 1)`), and `subdraw()` for the weapon emitted just its `gSPSegment` — 1 gfx command instead of ~150. All three VIEWMODEL-RESEARCH.md ranked suspects were ruled out by the same probe first: `field_87F==1` (gate open), `RootNode` valid, `numRecords 22 < 192` (pool fine), node walk visits 24+ valid `DL`/`SWITCH`/`BSP` nodes. **Fix:** `#ifdef PORT` → set the three fields explicitly (`zbufferenabled=TRUE; flags=3;`), N64 line verbatim under `#else`. ABI/layout only, no logic change. | **FIXED (`src/game/gunfire.c`, `#ifdef PORT`).** Build clean. `GE_DVM=1` post-fix: `flags=0x3`, weapon `subdraw()` now emits **153** gfx commands (was 1). Regression sweep crash-free. `GE_DVM` gate+render probes left in, env-gated (cf. `GE_D193*`). **Owed:** one BUNKER1 eyeball that the gun model is actually visible + correctly posed (headless can't see pixels; the DL is now provably generated). The committed `bunker1` golden will need re-baselining — the gun now renders in-frame. |
-| D217 | **1P weapon viewmodel + third-person Bond model textures render garbled — wrong/stale palette on model-DL CI textures (M-84, user QA; surfaced by D215 now that the viewmodel draws).** BUNKER1/Facility: the PP7 viewmodel has yellow+blue scrambled texels and a solid **green** patch by the hammer; Bond's in-game **watch face** shows the same green mismatch; user reports the **third-person Bond world model** does this "sometimes" too. Signature matches the **D161 family** — a CI-format tile drawn without the expected TLUT state, so fast3d's `import_texture` indexes a **stale `rdp.palette`**. D161 fixed the explicit `G_TT_NONE` case; this looks like model DLs not emitting `gDPLoadTLUT` through the port path, or the palette segment not resolving for weapon/character geometry. **Not a D215 regression** — D215 only un-gated the DL. | **Observed, not investigated (M-84).** Next: `GE_TEXDUMP` / `GE_DTEX` on a weapon texture in BUNKER1 — dump `fmt/siz/palfmt/palidx` + PPM, compare vs a clean world CI tile; check whether `gDPLoadTLUT` reaches `gfx_pc.cpp` for model DLs. |
+| D217 | **1P weapon viewmodel + third-person Bond model textures render garbled — wrong/stale palette on model-DL CI textures (M-84, user QA; surfaced by D215 now that the viewmodel draws).** BUNKER1/Facility: the PP7 viewmodel has yellow+blue scrambled texels and a solid **green** patch by the hammer; Bond's in-game **watch face** shows the same green mismatch; user reports the **third-person Bond world model** does this "sometimes" too. Signature matches the **D161 family** — a CI-format tile drawn without the expected TLUT state, so fast3d's `import_texture` indexes a **stale `rdp.palette`**. D161 fixed the explicit `G_TT_NONE` case; this looks like model DLs not emitting `gDPLoadTLUT` through the port path, or the palette segment not resolving for weapon/character geometry. **Not a D215 regression** — D215 only un-gated the DL. | **OPEN — observed, not investigated (M-84).** Next: `GE_TEXDUMP` / `GE_DTEX` on a weapon texture in BUNKER1 — dump `fmt/siz/palfmt/palidx` + PPM, compare vs a clean world CI tile; check whether `gDPLoadTLUT` reaches `gfx_pc.cpp` for model DLs. |
 | D218 | **Wide FOV exposes the per-level draw-distance / fog boundary — "blue artifacting" down long peripheral sightlines (M-84, user QA on the D211 FOV slider).** BUNKER→**Dam main tunnel** at `FovScale` ~150: geometry / backdrop past the level's fog-end distance shows at the widened frustum edges (blue = Dam's fog tint). Not a render bug — `fogLoadCurrentEnvironment` (`bgfog.c:305`) does `viSetZRange(Visibility.BlendMultiplier, Visibility.FarFog)`, so **`Visibility.FarFog` is both the far clip plane and the fog-saturation distance**; levels tune it for the stock ~60° FOV. | **Logged (M-84), fix proposed + parked.** Plan: `Video.DrawDistance` (percent, 100–400, default 100 ⇒ no-op) `#ifdef PORT` multiplier on `FarFog` at `bgfog.c:305` (+ the direct `arg0->Visibility.FarFog` reads just below, so fog stays consistent) plus `Video.DrawDistanceAutoFov` (0/1, default 1 — couples draw distance to `FovScale` unless `DrawDistance` is set explicitly). Clamp effective multiplier ≲2.5× (small znear ⇒ far-field z-fighting risk). |
 | D85 | room primary/secondary DL → `texLoadFromGdl` garbage | OPEN (safety-netted; widen/pool fixes landed, geometry now renders) |
 | D86 · D87 | modelInitRwData truncated ptr · attract-demo BE `ramromfilestructure` | resolved |